Most of us say we are going to play golf. Many of us think that “playing golf” simply entails traveling to the course, paying for our round, hitting some balls on the course, hitting shots and adding up the score after. But most of us aren’t actually playing golf, we’re instead playing “golf swing”.
Over-teaching How to Play “Golf Swing”
One of the biggest challenges we find with our clients is that they are playing Golf Swing when they come to us. They come to us often because they are not playing well or as well as they think they should.
Thousands of times we have been told “I hit it great on the range. Everyone says I have a great swing. But I am not scoring on the course.” Or they say “I play great in practice rounds and unimportant rounds but when it matters something is wrong and I score much higher.” Or some version of these comments.
With improvements to technology, equipment, and courses, you’d expect everyone to be playing really well on the course. The marketing certainly suggests this. But why aren’t we rapidly improving, especially if we’re buying the best equipment and using the best teachers?
The Golf Industry is constantly telling you how to swing and how to practice. The promise is that if you swing like this, like a Pro, that you will play better, hit the ball farther, and post lower scores.
Practicing Golf Too Much
If you’re not practicing golf the right way, it’s very possible to practice too often. If you repeatedly practice the same golf swing technique, you won’t be able to switch into a competitive mindset when you’re in competition. This will be counterproductive to your golf game.
What is the wrong way to practice golf? When you’re actually playing “golf swing.”
What Playing “Golf Swing” Looks Like
Your swing is broken down with video and other technology to pin point the key aspects of your swing that need to change. Your teacher gives you things to think about and drills to do to improve. You have golf swing keys and think about them constantly. You hit lots of balls working on those Swing Keys and Drills. On video your swing is better. On the range your ball striking is really good. Then you go to the course and it is not so good, or good for awhile and then not. It varies.
The problem is, it is not supposed to vary. Your shots are supposed to be consistent. You work so hard in practice to hit the same shot over and over. Your muscle memory is supposed to get really strong with all the balls you hit in practice.
You are religious about doing your routines just so. You are emphatic about making sure your swing keys are remembered. You monitor your swing to make sure your club and your body are in the right positions. Every routine is a carbon copy of the one before. Yet your swings and outcomes are not consistent through the round.
Why Playing Golf Swing Doesn’t Make For Great Golf
- First of all this game is diabolically difficult (see our article on why it is so hard).
- Second, you have been practicing your swing, not playing golf. How often do you get to hit the same shot over-and-over on the course?
- Third, you are not a machine. Our teachers teach us like we are machines with the videos and precise attention to alignment and body or club positions.
- Fourth, we work on the range with perfect lies and hit the same shot over and over with no worries about scoring.
None of this prepares us to play golf well.
How to Practice the Right Way
Wait, Don’t throw it all away. Don’t stop practicing, that is not my point. We all need to practice. Some of your practice should be the mechanical, swing key focused practice. But some of your practice needs to be “Play Style” practice. Practice playing golf shots on the range. One shot at a time with full routine and specific target and keep score. Put the club back in the bag. If you miss, you do not get to hit it again. That is not golf. The more real you make it the better.
We recommend starting with your mechanical practice and finishing with Play Style practice. We also recommend no mechanical practice before the round, only Play Style. This should help you start your rounds better.
If you’re practicing to Play “Golf Swing”, you’re going to have some real issues on the course. If you are focused on your alignment and swing keys over the ball you are operating in Left Brain mode. Left Brain is not athletic and so the swing will not be as good as you could do. Focusing on your swing means you are not focusing on the shot. Monitoring and trying to control your swing while swinging means you are disconnected from the shot. Your nervous system is not fast enough to actually adjust the swing effectively while it’s happening. This monitoring and trying to control the swing in Left Brain mode results in in-consistent swings and outcomes! This hurts your confidence and raises your arousal level.
Higher arousal will change your golf swing. We know from long experience that if you care about scoring well, you go up the arousal scale when you play. Your arousal level on the course is probably higher than it ever is on the range or in a lesson. No amount of practice shots or muscle memory can fix this. Higher arousal changes your swing. Often old swing flaws come back.
So between operating in Left Brain mode and higher arousal your swing is different on the course than it was in practice or that practice round. When your outcome is not what you wanted the natural response is to try to fix your swing. This only makes you more Left Brained and less confident, and therefore more golf swing focused. Arousal is not coming down, and frustration is going up.
Develop Your Athletic Shot Process & Control Arousal
The Solution is to develop your Athletic Shot Process and Control of your Level of Arousal.
The first step of every pre-shot routine is Calculations. This is a very Left Brained activity. That is fine. Our Left Brains are good at analyzing and doing the math, making decisions. But the Left Brain needs to stop when the choices are made. From there on, you need to be operating in Right Brained athletic mode, imagining the ball flying and imagining how it will feel to strike the ball and send it out there. No checking your feet and alignment. No thoughts about your swing keys. No monitoring of your swing and whether it feels right or not. No trying to control it perfectly.
Awareness of and the ability to lower your level of arousal will give you back all of your athletic abilities and your great swing. We use our Mind Meter to give you the feedback you need to learn to do this well and quickly. Amazingly, you can actually hit the ball well and more consistently when you let yourself swing freely and athletically. We do it in the other sports. You need to do it in golf.
We teach this Athletic Shot Process to all of our clients in individual coaching and in our schools. We will be happy to work with you to develop yours. Every one is different. Your Athletic Shot Process will be unique to you. We use our Mind Meter in our coaching and schools too, and it is available for sale.
Stop Playing “Golf Swing”! This wonderful game is so much better when you play Golf!
Note: There are times when you already play golf. They mostly happen by accident and because you missed a shot. I am talking about those trouble shots. A Trouble Shot is one where your shot did not end on the fairway or on the green. You could be behind a tree, in deep rough or otherwise in a bad spot.
You have not practiced these recovery shots. There is nothing like them on the range. So your mental approach to them is different. That careful and deliberate pre-shot routine you use on the tees and fairways is not usable here. You have to create a shot, and the lie may be awkward. There may be a branch in your normal back swing. You may not have a clear path to the ball or clear sight of your target.
So what are you thinking about to play this shot? Your thoughts are on the shape of the shot you need. Your thoughts are on the way the club head needs to impact the ball to get that shape. You imagine how the ball will come out. You imagine how you will swing through the ball. You imagine a lot. And you play it, often well. Sometimes amazing. And yes, sometimes poorly but that is why we call it a trouble shot.
In this instance you were Playing Golf, Not Golf Swing! See you can do it differently! Contact us for more personalized tips and coaching.
I have suffered from playing “Golf Swing” for most of my golfing life dating back to 1990. I’m “mostly” self taught and I have played in and competed in Open Qualifiers, the Florida Space Coast “Tour”, and a few Ohio Opens. Do not be fooled by my age (59); I can hit with all low amateur and journeymen Pros and if I can just get my head right—-there really is no boundary yo my game. The best I’ve ever played was when I was deeply involved in a “heated disagreement” with my playing partner, oblivious to the golf course, until on Number 9 Teebox I was advised that I had just birdied the first 8 holes>>>Needless to say: I went on a bogey spree thru the remaining holes! There isn’t a shot I can’t hit but… sifting Back-and-forth thru about 7-10 different swings throughout a round has made my mind mush! On the greens, I bury anything inside ten feet…I find my most confidence on the putting green and that has never wavered. I’m a spot putter and could really care less “How” my putting stroke is or looks because my mind is and has been predicated on one simple Fail-Succeed thought: Make the ball roll over the spot I’ve chosen 12-24 inches in front of my ball! If I make the stroke and my ball rolls over my “spot”…I really don’t care if the ball goes in the hole or not, I consider the stroke a success! Perhaps you can help me? Text messages are fine…Thanks!
Hi Tim, This is one of the reasons I wrote the article, “Are You Playing Golf or “Golf Swing”?”. Your putting is much more athletic and simple mentally. But the Golf Swing focus has hurt so many players and created huge inconsistency. Too much to respond to you here. I will email directly.
All of my golf life, I have never really had to think about the mechanics of the swing. Maybe a small item or two, I just played. Now I want to make a swing change, and it’s driving me nuts on how hard it is to transfer it to the course. So I am sure there is a balance as to practice the move I want to do and when I play trust it and just play..
Easier said than done. I guess I was spoiled as a younger golfer. Now I think I have to relearn how to play and practice again?
HI Thomas, thanks for commenting and sorry for your struggles. This is so common. When we try to change our swings we are necessarily operating more left brained and focussed on our swings. On the range we can work on this with repetitive swings and get it to work. The golf course is different. There you have to do it the first time. If you are trying to do it by focussing on your swing keys, then you will be left brained and less athletic and you will be disrupting your swing program with additional mental signals. You have to practice playing golf shots after your work on your swing. Make it a much like golf as possible. No swing keys please. This will help you take your new swing to the course. Please be aware that significant swing change takes some players “years” to accomplish, even the Tour players. Try to emphasize more general Feelings of the swing without focussing on your swing. Keep your thoughts on the shot.
Tried some of your advice in this article.
“Try to emphasize more general Feelings of the swing without focussing on your swing. Keep your thoughts on the shot.”
Disclaimer: I really just pitch around on one of the (secluded) fairways wherever the ball may land.
For me drills are necessary because I lack the raw talent (in pretty much everything, totalimmersion swimming, lito breakthrough skiing, alexander technique for living real life 🙂 , so I was interested how much more fun the athletic mode is here, right brain, that you described.
It was more fun, then I took a two week break and came back. I could not hit anything and was digging divots, actually missing the ball completely in this new “athletic mode”.
At that point, I did not introduce any golf keys or drills, but rather alexander technique “feeling” keys while hovering over the ball waiting to swing (inhibited, paused, allowing room for different parts to release and register gravity, all movement pausible, reversible, etc). And then I tried to keep my eye on the shot, like be problem-solving, where am I going, the athletic part. Did the backswing and replaced the wedge exactly where I wanted it. That made a nice loft with no divot, and sort of got close to where I was trying to go.
This is probably enough for me, there are far too many golf drills and keys on youtube. I have a couple balance drills I may still do for swimming occasionally but I hate drills generally and no longer need the full totalimmersion menu. Haven’t skiied in decades (my socio-economic status has declined luckily 🙂 but I sure did the drills back then, and side-slipping is definitely not skiing, you want to limit your time with that stuff. I was also in a higher SES when I had 14 months of AT lessons back in the early 90s. The guy was a great teacher because I still recall that especially separation of parts stuff when I need it today. Will try again sometime, should be amusing, not frustrating he he…
Thanks for sharing your experience Rich. Our ability to swing varies with our attention and level of arousal. With that long break from any golf, is it possible that you were a little different than the first time you tried it? After you settled yourself(seems like what you were doing over the ball the second time) the swing worked better.
I found this article because I had the realization after listening to the audiobook, “Breathe GOLF: The Missing Link to a Winning Performance.” I have always played sports. When I started playing golf a kid, there were no lessons or tangible techniques. It was just playing golf with my strong baseball grip and athletic ability. But things changed in early adulthood. I coached high school golf and started a deep dive into the do’s and don’ts of the swing. Then stack and tilt was invented. So for the past 15-20 years, I’ve had the belief that there is a swing technique out there that I should commit to and use it. Lots of swing techniques to choose from. The YouTube rabbit hole is quite deep and wide. So I’ve developed the belief that if I can just find that technique that works for me, I’ll be consistent and golf will be fun again. Sometimes, I’ll switch between two or even three techniques in a single round of golf if things aren’t going well. This, of course, means I’m playing golf swing the entire round. In fact, I play golf swing so much, I’m incapable of just playing golf. Unfortunately, this has lead to anxiety towards the game and a beer habit before and during a round… because it quiets the “arousal.” I know that if I am to truly enjoy the game again, I must learn to play golf again. To have different expectations about why I play. I have to learn to be a kid again – play for fun. Golf does not define me. At 55, I would like to think I can find the wisdom.